Sunday, September 29, 2024

1843-Midshipman Marriott and the Indian Navy spirit allowance

 

Bombay harbour


Untold lives blog

Sharing stories from the past, worldwide

 

12 posts from December 2013

11 December 2013

Midshipman Marriott and the Indian Navy spirit allowance

In December 1843, the Bombay Government wrote to the Court of Directors of the East India Company stating that it had come to their attention that it was common practice in the Indian Navy to give the midshipmen a daily ration of spirits.  This routine had come to the attention of Government because of the conduct of Henry R Marriott, Midshipman of the East India Company's receiving ship Hastings.

Bombay harbourBombay Harbour from James Wales,Bombay views: twelve views of the island of Bombay and its vicinity(London, 1800)  Images OnlineNoc

On 13 September 1843, while the Hastings was at Bombay, Midshipman Marriott was left as the officer in charge.  The Commanding Officer Lieutenant Montriou had left the ship on an errand at about 2pm.  It was later reported to the Commission of Enquiry, that at 3pm Marriott ordered the Pursers’ Steward and the Master at Arms to issue him with one week’s allowance of spirits.  By 3.30pm Marriott was discovered passed out in the Captain’s bed, and could not be roused.  Joseph Johnston, the acting Quartermaster, carried the unfortunate Marriott down below to the Midshipmen’s berth.  Midshipman Bode reported to the Enquiry that when he came on board the ship in the late afternoon, he was told what had happened and found Marriott 'Lying down on a chest in the Gunroom, quite unable to move'.  On being pressed for a description of Marriott’s condition, Bode stated 'He was in a dead sleep, half naked and had been vomiting'.

In his defence, Marriott submitted a written statement.   He stated that finding himself in charge of the ship he felt free of the normal regulations which constituted the ordinary duties of a Midshipman, and that '…under the impression that I was free from control, and labouring at the time under the influence of depressed spirits…I was in a unlucky moment induced to take advantage of liberty which I conceived my temporary authority imparted, the result of which has been the unfortunate and degraded position in which I now find myself placed'.

The Bombay Government seems to have taken Marriott’s depression into account.  A stern warning was be issued to him regarding his conduct, along with such admonition as the Superintendent of the Indian Navy deemed most suitable and effectual.  However '…as the general character of Mr Marriott is not reported upon very unfavourably, the Governor in Council is not desirous of proceeding any further'.

Perhaps more ominously for the Indian Navy’s Midshipmen was the Bombay Government’s proposal that the allowance of spirits be altogether abolished, and replaced with some other form of compensation.  In reply, the Court of Directors stated that they thought Marriott had been treated too leniently, and that Lieutenant Montriou had been wrong to leave so young an officer in charge. They also agreed that it would be right to abolish the allowance of spirits for Midshipmen of the Indian Navy, and authorised the Bombay Government in all cases to substitute for their spirit ration an equivalent in money.

John O’Brien
Post 1858 India Office Records  Cc-by


Further Reading:

Proceedings connected with a proposition to abolish the allowance of spirits to the midshipmen of the Indian Navy, September to December 1843 [IOR/F/4/2053/93811]

Despatches to Bombay, August to November 1844 [IOR/E/4/1076 pp.108-110]

The story of another drunken sailor

Sea water desalination plan since many years; Mumbai Water Supply: Overflow In Monsoon, Cuts In Summer-

 



Mumbai lakes near full capacity at 99.44 per cent, ...

Mid-day
https://www.mid-day.com › Mumbai
water levels mumbai lakes from www.mid-day.com
1 day agoIn Middle Vaitarna 98.79 per cent, Upper Vaitarna 99.79 per cent, Bhatsa 99.35 per cent, Vihar 100 per cent and Tulsi 100 per cent of useful ...
 

Mumbai Water Supply: Overflow In Monsoon, Cuts In Summer!

The Mumbai Municipal Corporation supplies 3.8 billion litres of drinking water daily to the city against the estimated demand of 4.4 billion litres. There is no desilting work carried out in at least three of the seven reserviors in the last ten years, which affects its water holding capacities.

B N KumarUpdated: Saturday, September 21, 2024, 08:26 PM IST
article-image
Representation/File Image |

Have you ever wondered as to why Mumbai, an island city faces water shortages? Why every year April onwards Mumbaikars face water cuts and we have the dams overflowing during the monsoon? If the city has enough water with more than adequate rainfall, why do we have to resort to ratio water supply? With these questions in mind, I decided to seek answers from the authorities.

I filed an application under the Right to Information (RTI) Act with the State Urban Development (UDD) department. And their reply was astonishing as the department did not have any information on this. It is the responsibility of the UDD to oversee all the cities across the state and is supposed to keep a tab on rapid urbanisation. And drinking water supply is the most important aspect of the urban planning.

Small mercy that the UDD referred my RTI application to the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM). Mind you, MCGM is the richest civic body in Asia and Mumbai is the economic capital of India. But, the corporation’s replies to my queries from different water departments werereal eye-openers.

The officer from MCGM’s Ghatkopar Water Works responded saying that the Main Trunk overseas supply from Vihar and Tulsi lakes and there has been no desilting work undertaken at these water bodies.


There is, therefore no question of any money spent on this work, the response was signed by Assistant Engineer and Information Officer Peter Rodrigues.

The following response from the MGCM’s Hydraulic Engineering department at Kapurwadi, Thane said, “As per this office record, no desilting work (was) done in the lakes/reservoirs of Modaksagar, Tansa and Middle Vaitarna in the last ten years.” However, no word from the MCGM on desilting of the remaining two lakes - Bhatsa and Upper Vaitarana.

The seven lakes and reservoirs together supply a total of 3.8 billion litres of drinking water to Mumbai city daily against the estimated demand of 4.4 billion litres. It is no rocket science that desilting is needed to maintain the water holding capacity of lakes and reservoirs. In fact, MCGM this year allocated about Rs 250 crores for desilting of the city drains as part of the monsoon preparedness.

The piling up of the silt in the bottom of the lakes and reservoirs obviously leads to misleading data and even complacency that everything is hunky-dory on the waterfront, whereas the people are forced to go for water tanker supply.

This also leads to the multi-crore water tanker mafia racket ruling the city and suburbs with the operators charging as they wish. A valid question that arises is that from where do the tanker suppliers get their water from if the MCGM runs out of water?

The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) has noted that several metro cities such as Mumbai and Chennai have witnessed unprecedented flooding in recent years. Inadequacies of flood protection works, reduction in the water holding capacity of natural reservoirs in the basin due to progressive siltation, breaching of riverbanks, raising of riverbed caused by deposition of silt are among the reasons, the CPCB noted in its ‘Indicative Guidelines for Restoration of Water Bodies’ published five years ago.

We at NatConnect Foundation have, therefore, requested the Chief Minister of Maharashtra to appoint an expert committee – and not of politicians – to go into the technicalities, the process of desilting, disposal and management of the silt taken from the reservoirs.

There have been research reports that the lake-bottom silt is full of nutrition and it is quite useful for our farm lands which are losing top soil. Hence, this suggestion for action, as they say in legislative language!

(The author is a media veteran, an environmentalist and Director at NatConnect Foundation)

 
6 Dec 2023The plant is expected to produce 200 million litres of potable water per day by treating sea water that will be augmented to 400 million litres ...


8 Aug 2024 — The project is supposed to add 200 MLD of water to the current daily supply of 3,850 MLD, and the capacity of the plant can be later doubled.
4 Aug 2024 — Congress's Sachin Sawant alleges cartelisation in the tendering process for a Rs 3600 crore desalination plant at Manori.

 
 ...............................................................................................................................................
 
 
3 May 2016 — The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJPon Monday demanded that police take action against the 'tanker mafia' by booking them under the Maharashtra Co

Tanker mafia earning Rs 8000-10000 crore annually from ...

Moneycontrol
https://www.moneycontrol.com › ... › VIDEOS



3 Jun 2019The answer is simple. Tankers spell money. This is often in collusion with the authorities of the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) ...
 
21 Jan 2022 — The BJP Friday urged the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to take strong measures to stop the alleged water theft by the tanker mafia.


12 Jun 2024 — The Supreme Court on Wednesday warned the Delhi government to rein in the tanker mafia and wastage of water in the national capital.
25 Mar 2023 — Responding to allegations by BJP MLA Ashish Shelar in the state assembly on Friday that a tanker mafia doing business worth Rs 10000 crore ...
 

inquiry 

result?any action taken?

older news
9 Apr 2019 — Well owners-tanker mafia depleting ground water. Water being drawn illegally from a spot near Kayani Restaurant (Photo by Sachin Haralkar). BMC ...
3 Nov 2019 — The water mafia exploit the vulnerability of people in a city, where obtaining a few buckets of clean water is a luxury for some.

 ...............................................................................................................................................
 
older news

8 Jul 2019 — One is water theft remember the tanker mafia (https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/eye-on-india/videos/tanker-mafia-earning-rs-8000-10000-crore ...
15 Jul 2019 — This is where the state has to ensure that distribution mafia-like operations — like that of water tankers (https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/ ...
older news
20 Aug 2017 — This is suspected to be a conspiracy of the water mafias, who used to sell water at exorbitant rates in nexus with BMC officials, so as to ...
25 Apr 2016 — BJP claims BMC-water tanker mafia nexus, lodges FIR. BJP MP Kirit Somaiya alleged that the civic water department was helping the tanker mafias.
29 Apr 2024 — The Congress leaders are making money by running water tanker mafia in Bengaluru, he said at an election rally in Bagalkot on Monday.

 ...............................................................................................................................................